Read
2 minute read
November 16, 2026
2 minute read
The U.S. Patent and Trademark Office has again changed how institution decisions will be made in inter partes review (IPR) and post-grant review (PGR) proceedings. Under a November 10 memorandum from USPTO Director Squires, administrative patent judges at the Patent Trial and Appeal Board (PTAB) will once again decide whether petitions satisfy the substantive requirements for institution. The Director, however, will continue to review non-merits considerations, including whether petitions should be denied for discretionary reasons. The new procedure takes effect November 16, 2026.
Under the revised procedure, the Director will first determine whether institution should be denied based on non-merits considerations. Petitions surviving that review will proceed to a three-judge PTAB panel to determine whether the statutory merits threshold for institution has been satisfied. This marks a partial return to the PTAB’s historical practice, after Director Squires took responsibility for both discretionary and merits-based institution decisions in October 2025.
There are two other notable changes. First, the PTAB panel deciding institution will not be the panel that conducts the instituted proceeding. Second, institution decisions need only “briefly address” the merits and provide sufficient explanation as to whether the petitioner has satisfied the institution standard for at least one claim and asserted ground. The Board need not address every challenged claim, ground, or argument.
The memorandum also instructs PTAB panels to deny institution when the petitioner has not made the requisite showing for a substantial majority of the challenged claims. Although the statutory threshold for IPR institution remains a reasonable likelihood of success as to at least one challenged claim, this guidance may make the breadth of a petition and the strength of its claim-by-claim analysis increasingly important to the institution decision.
What This Means for IPR Petitioners and Patent Owners
The new procedure creates a clearer division between discretionary considerations and the merits. Petitioners must first navigate the Director’s non-merits review before having the technical and legal merits considered by PTAB judges. Patent owners, in turn, will continue to have opportunities to oppose institution based on both discretionary considerations and the substantive merits of the petition.
Importantly, the change leaves intact the Director’s increasingly significant discretionary review, which in recent guidance has expanded beyond traditional parallel-litigation considerations to include factors such as domestic manufacturing, small-business status, and broader economic and public interests.
The new merits guidance may also affect how petitions are structured. Petitioners will need to consider whether challenging additional claims with comparatively weaker grounds could undermine institution of the petition as a whole, while patent owners may have greater incentive to demonstrate weaknesses across a significant number of challenged claims. And because a different panel will preside over the trial, parties should be cautious about treating the institution decision as necessarily indicative of how the trial panel will ultimately view the merits.
Michael Best’s Post-Grant team has represented both petitioners and patent owners in IPR and other post-grant proceedings before the PTAB and continues to monitor developments in USPTO institution practice.



